Citation:

Sree Lakshmi Vineetha Bitragunta, 2022. "Field-Test Analysis and Comparative Evaluation of LTE and PLC Communication Technologies in the Context of Smart Grid", ESP Journal of Engineering & Technology Advancements 2(3): 154-161.

Abstract:

In smart grid systems, the facilitation of unimpeded communication among diverse assets, devices, and grid operators is paramount for optimal functionality and real-time surveillance. This study explores the application of two leading communication technologies—wireless LTE (Long-Term Evolution) and broadband Power Line Communication (PLC)—within a real-world smart grid framework, particularly concentrating on the 'Smart Grid Demonstrator Sonderbuch' project. This study introduces a cutting-edge hybrid methodology by simultaneously deploying and evaluating these two communication frameworks in parallel to investigate their efficiency across different operational environments. The study provides a fresh appraisal of the distinct benefits and drawbacks of both technologies in terms of network latency, reliability, and resistance to temporary interruptions, employing sophisticated data analytics and real-time observation methods for an exhaustive comparative assessment. The results reveal that, despite broadband PLC exceeding LTE concerning network latency, LTE shows improved resilience to temporary disturbances, resulting in a higher overall reliability. Moreover, the research endorses a refined hybrid deployment framework for future smart grid executions, leveraging the strengths of both communication technologies to enhance system resilience and ensure continuous grid management.

References:

[1] Abdul, R., Beig. "Power semiconductor devices." (2016) . doi: 10.1016/B978-0-12-804448-3.00013-X.

[2] Ujwal, Radhakrishna."Modeling gallium-nitride based high electron Mobility transistors : linking device physics to high voltage and high frequency circuit design." (2016).

[3] Gourab, Sabui., Peter, J., Parbrook., Peter, J., Parbrook., Miryam, Arredondo-Arechavala., Z., J., Shen."Modeling and simulation of bulk gallium nitride power semiconductor devices." AIP Advances, (2016). doi: 10.1063/1.4948794.

[4] Takeshi, Mizoguchi., Toshiyuki, Naka., Yuta, Tanimoto., Yasuhiro, Okada., Wataru, Saito., Mitiko, Miura-Mattausch., Hans, Jurgen, Mattausch."Analysis of GaN-HEMTs switching characteristics for power applications with compact model including parasitic contributions." (2016). doi: 10.1109/ISPSD.2016.7520829.

[5] Beatrix, Weiss., Richard, Reiner., Patrick, Waltereit., Rudiger, Quay., Oliver, Ambacher."Analysis and modeling of GaN-based multi field plate Schottky power diodes."(2016).

[6] Sen, Huang., Shu, Yang., Zhikai, Tang., Mengyuan, Hua., Xinhua, Wang., Ke, Wei., Qilong, Bao., Xinyu, Liu., Jing, Chen."Device physics towards high performance GaN-based power electronics." (2016). doi: 10.1360/SSPMA2016-00220.

[7] Ramchandra, M., Kotecha., Yuzhi, Zhang., Arman, Ur, Rashid., Thomas, A., Vrotsos., H., Alan, Mantooth."A physics-based compact device model for GaN HEMT power devices."(2016).doi: 10.1109/WIPDA.2016.7799919.

[8] Sudip, Ghosh., Sheikh, Aamir, Ahsan., Avirup, Dasgupta., Sourabh, Khandelwal., Yogesh, Singh, Chauhan. "GaN HEMT modeling for power and RF applications using ASM-HEMT."(2016). doi: 10.1109/ICEMELEC.2016.8074569.

[9] Dhruvin, Patel., Mohamed, Imran, Noor, Mohamed., Syed, Zain, Raza, Mehdi., Fiona, Williams., Abhinav, Sadu., Ferdinanda, Ponci., Antonello, Monti. "Investigating the performance of QoS enabled LTE networks for IEC 61850 based smart grid applications."(2016). doi: 10.1109/ENERGYCON.2016.7513965.

[10] Charalampos, Kalalas., Linus, Thrybom., Jesus, Alonso-Zarate. "Cellular Communications for Smart Grid Neighborhood Area Networks: A Survey." IEEE Access,(2016). doi: 10.1109/ACCESS.2016.2551978 .

[11] Dejana, Čučak. "30. Physics-based Analytical Modelling and Optimization of the GaN HEMT with the Field-Plate Structure for Application in High-Frequency Switching Converters." undefined (2017).

[12] Gilberto, Curatola., Giovanni, Verzellesi. "31. Modelling of GaN HEMTs: From Device-Level Simulation to Virtual Prototyping." undefined (2017). doi: 10.1007/978-3-319-43199-4_8.

[13] Anwar, Jarndal., Ammar, B., Kouki."Efficient modeling of GaN HEMTs for linear and nonlinear circuits design." International Journal of Numerical Modelling-electronic Networks Devices and Fields,(2017). doi: 10.1002/JNM.2100

[14] Bo, Søborg, Petersen., Henrik, W., Bindner., Bjarne, Poulsen., Shi, You. “Smart grid communication infrastructure comparison-for distributed control of distributed energy resources using internet of things devices."(2018). doi: 10.18178/IJEETC.7.1.7-14.

[15] Juho, Markkula., Jussi, Haapola."Ad Hoc LTE Method for Resilient Smart Grid Communications." Wireless Personal Communications, (2018). doi: 10.1007/S11277-017-5018-1.

[16] William, Flerchinger., Robert, Ferraro., Chris, Steeprow., Michael, Mills-Price., J., W., Knapek. “Third-Generation Cellular and Wireless Serial Radio Communications: Field Testing for Smart Grid Applications." IEEE Industry Applications Magazine, undefined (2018). doi: 10.1109/MIAS.2017.2740475.

[17] Desong, Bian., Murat, Kuzlu., Manisa, Pipattanasomporn., Saifur, Rahman., Di, Shi. "Performance evaluation of communication technologies and network structure for smart grid applications." Iet Communications,(2019). doi: 10.1049/IET-COM.2018.5408.

[18] R., Jędrychowski."The use of PLC controllers to simulate data exchange processes in Smart Grid."(2019). doi: 10.1109/PAEE.2019.8788982.

[19] Soumya, P., Dash., Sandeep, Joshi., Ranjan, K., Mallik. “Smart Grid Network With D2D Communication and Coherent PLC: Error Analysis." IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology,(2020). doi: 10.1109/TVT.2019.2953273.

Keywords:

Advanced Communication Methodologies, Grid Operator Communication, Hybrid LTE and PLC Systems, Communication Efficiency Assessment, Smart Grid Operational Environments, Continuous Grid Management.